All the teams with god-tier recruitment like Leicester, Dortmund, Sevilla, Ajax, Southampton, Chelsea and er Leeds have a long-standing director of football.
Plenty of teams with terrible recruitment have a director of football as well. Spurs seem to flip their director of football every couple of seasons, which makes a mockery of the point of having one.
In the end having someone with that job title isn’t a quick fix. It’s about finding someone really good and committing to that model and vision for 10 years.
I think even when we had Orta, we didn’t fully commit to it. It was as clear as day which signings were Orta ones, which were Gibson ones, which were Karanka ones and probably some Gary Gill magic scouting team ones too. Have a look at our transfers from that period, there’s no way the same brain was signing Jelle Vossen, Rhodes & Downing, and Victor Valdes.