I know plenty of people are going to say, get a gait analysis done, but… I used to get ASICS cumulus but the guy in the shop said they changed the soles and to get Brooks Ghost. Just been looking online and not sure if they have been discontinued but Brooks seem to have a couple of new shoes. My question, can anyone recommend a similar trainer to the old Cumulus or Brooks Ghost. I have problems with my knees so don’t go out running bug do use them for walking and an every day trainer. Any advice appreciated.
Running shoes
- Thread starter Zanzibobs
- Start date
ThatFragranceGuy
Well-known member
Use website runrepeat
It aggregates reviews and does tear downs, links to cheapest versions in each colour ways etc
Else all you get is anecdotes which might work for some people and not for others, so better to get a more detailed opinion and a wider net of comments
runrepeat.com
You can apply loads of filters
It aggregates reviews and does tear downs, links to cheapest versions in each colour ways etc
Else all you get is anecdotes which might work for some people and not for others, so better to get a more detailed opinion and a wider net of comments
100+ Running Shoe Reviews (2024) | RunRepeat
689 running shoe reviews tested in our lab in 2024. Read our in-depth reviews and compare shoes on a variety of metrics.
runrepeat.com
You can apply loads of filters
Heine_Otto
Well-known member
I think the old 'gait analysis' is over-rated.
As an experiment I did it with 3 friends at Up and Running in Darlo. We all run differently, we all got recommended the same trainers. Obviously they had stock needing shifting.
I've recently tried Saucony and Hoka trainers for running, both very comfortable and lightweight.
If you don't go running do you really want trainers? Thought about Skechers? Mine are the most comfortable shoes I own.
As an experiment I did it with 3 friends at Up and Running in Darlo. We all run differently, we all got recommended the same trainers. Obviously they had stock needing shifting.
I've recently tried Saucony and Hoka trainers for running, both very comfortable and lightweight.
If you don't go running do you really want trainers? Thought about Skechers? Mine are the most comfortable shoes I own.
DidsburySmog92
Well-known member
I have had all the analysis stuff done over the years. I always come back to New Balance 1080s or 880s. I just picked up a new pair of 1080s on Sunday. Utilitarian running shoes for road running. Will do you about 400k at good pace. I think you can get them for between £120-160 depending on if anywhere has them on sale so they are more expensive than the ASICS cumulus. Good cushioning if you have back issues.
starplayer
Well-known member
Most comfortable walking trainers I have ever had are Onitsuka Tiger New York. It is such a subjective thing though.
ThePrisoner
Well-known member
Has to be these.
newyddion
Well-known member
New Balance 1080 or 880
- 1080 slightly more cushioned and softer
- 880 slightly more stable and firmer
- 1080 often looked at more for speed thanks to the rocker
- 880 available in narrow, standard, wide and extra wide
- 1080 has a lower heel toe drop
ThatFragranceGuy
Well-known member
Hoka stuff can be really good albeit often a bit gaudy, I've had a few pairs. Really good for cushioning in the oneone range
MaximoParkEnd
Member
I always wore ASICS, til they changed them. I was told that 361s were being made to the old ASICS patterns. Been wearing 361s for the past 5 years. No idea whether they are really the same as old ASICS, but I like them.
Might be worth a look.
Might be worth a look.
I know you said plenty of people will say it...but seriously, get gait analysis done at a decent running shop (not sport direct), I snapped my achilles a couple of years ago and as a result am very prone to plantar fasciitis and other foot pain. I went to a well known local running shop and they did a free analysis, and they found a specific Brooks shoe (Brooks Beast) that felt like I was walking on a cloud instead of everyday feeling like I had lego in my shoe. It made an absolutely massive difference and enabled me to get out running again.
(for specifics, the Brooks beast is a pretty hefty shoe for a running shoe but it gives massive support and comfort)
(for specifics, the Brooks beast is a pretty hefty shoe for a running shoe but it gives massive support and comfort)
Hap
Well-known member
I had a similar experience. I wished I’d had gait analysis years earlier. Changed my whole running (in my case) experience
go-nads!
Well-known member
I have these currently and love them. Had a pair of Hoka last set and they were good but prefer the new balance.
BillyGoat95
Active member
Gait analysis was a game changer for me as well - had a pair of Mizuno Wave Inspire 13's first and currently loving my Brooks Adrenaline GTS 20's 
Plenty of stability and support without feeling *too* cushioned and artificial. Like someone above said though, it's so so subjective.
Plenty of stability and support without feeling *too* cushioned and artificial. Like someone above said though, it's so so subjective.
Holgate69
New member
I used ASICS for ages but i started get few niggles in my knees.
Switched to Brookes (Ghost) 18 months ago.
Ive had no problems since.
Very comfortable & give great support.