The issue is his defending - if it was a weakness in the Championship what will it be in the Premier League. He also hasn't the upper body strength of the average full back nowdays - he's not built that way, reminds me of the full back we had that went to Villa and Cardiff. Local lad than came up through the academy, but I can't remember his name. Giles is a bit better crosser but they had a similar physique. I would say Giles is a £5m to £6m player. Spence in contrast was stronger on the ball, difficult to shove off and won alot of tackles, as well as quick, also had more of an eye for goal. Spence was £12.5m and failed to play in the Premier League.