“Why have Sunderland often struggled when facing Middlesbrough away?” [Roker Report] 31/01/24.

r00fie1

Well-known member
* An interesting article, published this morning, with the hardcore Deckchair fans telling each other how the game on Sunday isnt a "derby"..........................


1706701071300.png

Gav says…


The derby that isn’t a derby…except it is a derby, but not to everyone and only to some.

And most of those who think it’s a derby are from Teesside, who don’t like being seen as insignificant in comparison to Newcastle, and Sunderland fans in the main will trip over themselves to tell anyone it’s not a derby, but it’s the same routine every time we play them.

The fact is that our record against Middlesbrough is absolutely dismal and particularly at their place, where since 1954, we’ve won just three times to their thirty five.

That isn’t by accident. Sure, you expect the home team to win more than they lose over time against any given opponent, but those numbers are dismal.

What it tells me is that more often than not, Middlesbrough recognise the significance of the occasion, and we don’t, so how do we fix that?

Well, I’m not sure we really can, and not organically, anyway.

They simply care more about playing Sunderland than Sunderland do about playing them, and we can’t change that.

However, I do think that’s where the senior staff and players must step in.

We should be reminding the players in the week building up to the game of how significant this is to Middlesbrough, and I even think using the club’s poor record down the years at Ayresome Park and then the Riverside as a tool for motivation is something we should do.

We rarely turn up on the big occasions and if Michael Beale can become the fourth man to manage Sunderland to a victory on Teesside in the last seventy years, it’ll go a long way as he bids to earn the respect of a fanbase that still needs convincing he’s the man for the job.

Soccer - FA Barclays Premiership - Middlesbrough v Sunderland - Riverside Stadium
Photo by Owen Humphreys - PA Images/PA Images via Getty Images

Malc Dugdale says…


My view is quite simple: for us, it’s just another game against another Championship team, even if it isn’t for them.

We’d like to win every game at the level we’re at, but in reality we never will.

Accepting that, we want the Lads to play well and put a shift in, just the same as any other fixture. I accept that we’ll lose some games as we build back towards a position where that stat will decrease, but if we play well and don’t win, we move on to the next one.

In recent years, they’ve wanted it more than us, as I believe they see this as more than just a normal game.

We should maybe do better in knowing that, and maybe this week we will, but on average we don’t excel because we aren’t really that bothered about anything other than the three points.

I suppose that’s what happens when you exist on the edge of North Yorkshire. You aren’t really a rival for proper Yorkshire teams and you aren’t seen as part of the North East's main rivalry, so you hang on to anything.

I really hope we improve this record, and we’re also hoping to see an improvement in form and league points after a bit of a dip before the win against Stoke, but where the Newcastle game got me going and was something I’d never miss, this is ‘just’ Boro, so it’s nothing special.

Let’s do the job and move on.



Tom Albrighton says…


I think it’s an easy answer, and it’s because to Middlesbrough it’s a derby and to us, it just isn’t.

I’m not advocating for a sudden shift in mentality but even games against the likes of Coventry and Leeds United seem to have carried more weight than those against Middlesbrough.

For the hosts, unless they suddenly end up playing Hartlepool, we’re their nearest ‘real’ rivals and whilst their attentions are regularly drawn to Sunderland and the magnitude of our presence, they often find us looking a different way, much like that meme of the guy checking out a woman whilst holding another hand.

Ultimately, I think this gives Boro the edge. By convincing themselves that this game is a derby, it allows them to tap into the increase in energy, the buzz and all that comes with it.

As a result, we’re often found wanting because try as we might, it’s almost an impossible task to convince ourselves this game is special.

So for now, Boro hold the cards and they probably will for a long while yet whilst this fixture exists.

It may be foolish pride or just foolishness full stop, but I’d rather that than lowering ourselves to pretend our rivals are some Yorkshiremen from Wish rather than that lot up the road.

Midd’boro v Sund’land Reid
https://rokerreport.sbnation.com/20...ften-struggled-when-facing-middlesbrough-away

 
Last edited:
The definition of a derby is "a sports competition, especially a game of football, between two teams from the same city or area" - If the area is the North East, then it's as much a derby as Hartlepool v Newcastle, Darlo v Sunderland, Redcar v Billingham etc... If they want to be pedantic they are closer to Gateshead and South Shields than they are Newcastle...

SoL to RS - 32.3mile.
Ipswich to Norwich 44.9mile, Cardiff to Swansea 42.9, Man U to Liverpool is 42.1mile. Their rhetoric is nonsense and they know it.

They have a CLOSER rival.
They do not have a closer league rival.
They have a more fierce rivalry with Newcastle.
Unless Darlo/Hartlepool climb the leagues then Sunderland will be our closest opponent.
Unless Hebburn/Gateshead climb the leagues then Newcastle are their closest opponent.
If they lose, they brush it off as if its just another match and often use this angle in pre-match build-up. If they beat us they make out its our cup final - their rhetoric doesn't change.
When our score is read out at the SoL, and we're behind you'll hear cheers... They don't do this for every game, so why ours if they don't care?

It's a derby, not their most fierce but i know a handful of them lot and they all agree with the above but when the ***** get online they spout this nonsense but i think everyone is wise to it now.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It makes me laugh that they try to claim that they treat it like any other game.

I can still remember when we played them in the FA cup a few years back and they brought a massive following. Large groups of them were singing outside the stadium, mainly provocative songs and seemed a lot more hyped up for the game than Boro fans.

If anyone was treating it as a cup final that day it was them.
 
It makes me laugh that they try to claim that they treat it like any other game.

I can still remember when we played them in the FA cup a few years back and they brought a massive following. Large groups of them were singing outside the stadium, mainly provocative songs and seemed a lot more hyped up for the game than Boro fans.

If anyone was treating it as a cup final that day it was them.
I suppose the telling thing would be to compare their crowds at home when they play us and when they play other sides, is the crowd against us higher than their average?

I can't be bothered checking but I would say that's where the answer is.
 
What absolute nonsense those comments are. Regardless of who thinks it's a derby and who doesn't, the argument that we win more because our players try harder than theirs is ridiculous.

We've just had better players than them for almost all of the past 40+ years, that's why we win more.
 
As Newcastle float away on their blood soaked oil tanker to the elite, I imagine the rivalry between us and Sunderland will become more intense. Both clubs are operating at a similar level and fighting for the same goals. All it takes is a couple of tasty games to heat up a rivalry like we have had in the past with Championship clubs who aren't local to us.
 
Football moves fast and they have lost their identity.. they held on to the mackem v toon rivalry as they dropped down the leagues.. forever the poorer and less successful relative they have embarrassed themselves in there constantly fawning and desperation towards the Geordies.. so much so THAT has become their identity.. the pathetic snivelling gimp that does everything in their power for attention from their black and white wet dream..

As much as they scream and shout that there is no rivalry between boro and sunlun.. they are right! Who the fook are they? The young supporters don’t even have Sunderland on their radar! The club that painted their bar to look like a richer local team.. the club that made scarves for a team they wanted to be special friends with.. packed lunches, sandwiches and biscuits.. embarrassing!

The best thing about Sunderland in the past 40 years? Tony Mowbray

I hope we pump them real bad. 3 points like any other game.. but I don’t like how they constantly have our name on their lips.. constantly spouting.. ffs lads.. give it a rest you sad chunts.. UTB
 
Looks like this insistence that it isn't a derby, despite the fairly small 27 mile distance, is costing them a lot of points and success.

What's the record at Sunderland? Presumably we pummel them there every time too since it means so much more to us.

Same with Newcastle, they just can't compete with us either in an 11 v 11 situation.

I'm sick of Arsenal caring more about their matches against us, just stop Gunners. We don't care about you, okay?
 
Last edited:
Rivals.. the world is a big place! Gone are the days where we were fighting over jobs and car factories.. leave the Americanised fake showdowns.. plenty of teams not to like still.. there’s plenty to go round.

Spurs and Chelsea have to be up there

Sunderland need to meet up with Coventry and get some half and half scarves sorted.. or maybe Derby.. depending on how the season pans out. Sad clubs
 
"We rarely turn up on the big occasions"

I guess they don't turn up for the small occasions either. What else could account for their dismal record at our place?
What is the big occasion? Are they suggesting that boro is a big occasion and they bottle it. big occasion because.. we’re a better team that is fairly close.
 
As Newcastle float away on their blood soaked oil tanker to the elite, I imagine the rivalry between us and Sunderland will become more intense.

I dont, because as illustrated in that article their arrogance knows no bounds and they'll convince themselves that Newcastle are occupying their rightful position, and it's just a matter of time before they're talked about in the same breath.

In reality they're what you'd get if your ordered a Geordie from Wish (to nick their analogy) and will always be seen that way by everyone but a few idiots from a few pit villages in County Durham.
 
What is the big occasion? Are they suggesting that boro is a big occasion and they bottle it. big occasion because.. we’re a better team that is fairly close.
That's Mackem myopia for you. We're too far away to be anything other than a blur because of the smog.
 
Of course it's a derby. They know it, we know it, they just like to kick and scream and pretend we're insignificant to them. If that's the case, why do they bang on about it so much and let it wind them up!?

They probably just hate the fact that as local rivals, we're simply better than them and have been for years.
 
Their excuses are inaccurate, granted it’s a bigger a game for Boro and we raise our game but what about when we play Newcastle? A game we’d love to win but our record in those clashes is poor in comparison to the Tees-Wear games.
 
Back
Top