Are Sunderland fans the most delusional fans in the country?

In the 1982/3 season I used to get United service Bus for Boro home games from Newcastle to the Boro. It went through Durham City and quite of the Durham villages, Sedgefield and Stockton. Boro fans got on in Sedgefield and alot in Stockton, but none that I was aware of before Sedgefield. It wasn't a great season we averaged 10,000. Also I got on the bus about 11am to get into Boro for about 1pm, so it may have been a bit early. If I got the train down the East Coast of Durham, no Boro fans got on till Seaton Carew.

The same season coming from Whitby on a United Service Bus, Boro fans started getting on in Loftus and constant after that. They were really hard times say season 1984/5 with only 4,000 at some games. A lot of the women on the bus had adult children that had moved away. At the time I thought by 2023 no one would be left in East Cleveland. Whitby was about 75% Leeds then - most Whitby people have never been to Teesside, even they went shopping etc outside Whitby, it was Scarborough or York if they were posh. A coach went to every Leeds home game, it used to be 2 coaches in the 1970s from Whitby. Whitby is 33 miles to Middlesbrough and Leeds is 75 miles.

I think the Boro suffered a bit from been a borderland between Durham and Yorkshire, in Yorkshire but not fully In Yorkshire psychologically and not in Durham. Socially it has been different to me too with probably 80% of its population from other parts of the UK and Ireland. Making it a bit of an Island. Add in very heavy industry and the fact that it was a complete new town made it different and a bit scary to the surrounding rural populations. The large population influx in the 1850-1880 period had never happened on such a scale in the UK(and I don't think has happened since) and it left a mass of people in a small area needing regular employment and poverty followed when ther Iron industry failed to expand, so the area became associated with working class/poverty/struggle for a lot of years after 1880. The legacy of this is a tight band of bonded supporters with the football club woven psychologically into the Town and its close surrounding areas roughly defined as Teesside i.e there was no Middlesbrough FC before Middlesbrough but also no Middlesbrough before Middlesbrough FC, in the minds of the 21st Century people. Reading 3,000 Boro fans travelled to Sunderland for a friendly in 1883 shocked me, but its showed the connection with the new inhabitants and their football club was woven many years ago.
 
In the 1982/3 season I used to get United service Bus for Boro home games from Newcastle to the Boro. It went through Durham City and quite of the Durham villages, Sedgefield and Stockton. Boro fans got on in Sedgefield and alot in Stockton, but none that I was aware of before Sedgefield. It wasn't a great season we averaged 10,000. Also I got on the bus about 11am to get into Boro for about 1pm, so it may have been a bit early. If I got the train down the East Coast of Durham, no Boro fans got on till Seaton Carew.

The same season coming from Whitby on a United Service Bus, Boro fans started getting on in Loftus and constant after that. They were really hard times say season 1984/5 with only 4,000 at some games. A lot of the women on the bus had adult children that had moved away. At the time I thought by 2023 no one would be left in East Cleveland. Whitby was about 75% Leeds then - most Whitby people have never been to Teesside, even they went shopping etc outside Whitby, it was Scarborough or York if they were posh. A coach went to every Leeds home game, it used to be 2 coaches in the 1970s from Whitby. Whitby is 33 miles to Middlesbrough and Leeds is 75 miles.

I think the Boro suffered a bit from been a borderland between Durham and Yorkshire, in Yorkshire but not fully In Yorkshire psychologically and not in Durham. Socially it has been different to me too with probably 80% of its population from other parts of the UK and Ireland. Making it a bit of an Island. Add in very heavy industry and the fact that it was a complete new town made it different and a bit scary to the surrounding rural populations. The large population influx in the 1850-1880 period had never happened on such a scale in the UK(and I don't think has happened since) and it left a mass of people in a small area needing regular employment and poverty followed when ther Iron industry failed to expand, so the area became associated with working class/poverty/struggle for a lot of years after 1880. The legacy of this is a tight band of bonded supporters with the football club woven psychologically into the Town and its close surrounding areas roughly defined as Teesside i.e there was no Middlesbrough FC before Middlesbrough but also no Middlesbrough before Middlesbrough FC, in the minds of the 21st Century people. Reading 3,000 Boro fans travelled to Sunderland for a friendly in 1883 shocked me, but its showed the connection with the new inhabitants and their football club was woven many years ago.
It just doesn’t matter we are still up there with the best supported clubs per head of population, way way above Leeds or Sunderland.
 
Sedgefield is definitely more Boro as I said earlier. Beyond that it dissipates quickly. Places like Trimdon have Boro fans, but it's not the majority. Go beyond that to Ferryhill, Bowburn and Wingate and it's massively Sunderland with just a smattering of Boro fans.
I’m actually quite relieved that places like Ferryhill and Bowburn are not Boro strongholds….
 
I've just watched this analysis of the game from a Sunderland fan with AI voice over. He praises us at times but soon reverts to type about it being a meaningless result and game. I wonder why he felt the need to do a YouTube video on then? 🤣 🤣 🤣

For some reason he decided not to show the last goal, I wonder if he was one of the fans who had to leave for the fire drill practice. 🤣🤣🤣

 
North Yorkshire is mainly sheep so irrelevant, the population density of South Durham outside Teesside is nothing compared to North Durham. The density of population of the old Durham pit villages & towns stops dead south of Peterlee / Bishop, sheep below. Hartlepool has a simple train ride to Sland so always split, Darlo has a simple train ride to Newcastle and they always used to dual purpose their black & white scarves. We don't have a natural population catchment outside Teesside like Wearside does, simples.
I think we all know these things that said with any noticeable success we would imo attract a huge following from north York’s surely we should target it. It’s a county of 1 million people and we should do imo to make it red and white
 
It just doesn’t matter we are still up there with the best supported clubs per head of population, way way above Leeds or Sunderland.
Sheffield clubs stand out for me. Big city around 500,000 but for two big clubs Burnley aswell. We will be up there but them must be the top 3 imo.
 
I can tell you where I live in Durham alot of people support boro it's not a tiny population
We don’t have a huge following in durham it seems. Our baseline support comes from Teesside that said we still have big support across stokelsy Whitby northaleton and we do pull a good following from. Our catchment area is probably around 700,000 900,000 for Sunderland and about 1.2 million for Newcastle.
 
Sheffield clubs stand out for me. Big city around 500,000 but for two big clubs Burnley aswell. We will be up there but them must be the top 3 imo.
Other substantial clubs around Sheffield as well like Rotherham, Barnsley, Chesterfield and both Wednesday and Sheff U are well supported so definitely a football city.

Burnley definitely pull in a big crowd for their catchment I think they are a bit like us as a club but not as big, I actually think the top two are us and Burnley.
 
We don’t have a huge following in durham it seems. Our baseline support comes from Teesside that said we still have big support across stokelsy Whitby northaleton and we do pull a good following from. Our catchment area is probably around 700,000 900,000 for Sunderland and about 1.2 million for Newcastle.
I think Newcastle and Sunderland are about a million each when you include Blyth, North and South Shields, Whitley Bay/Tynemouth, Washington, Durham etc plus Northumberland and Durham counties. Newcastle perhaps 200k more as you say. I also know a few Scottish people who come down to Newcastle for matches.

I think ours is 500k.
 
Other substantial clubs around Sheffield as well like Rotherham, Barnsley, Chesterfield and both Wednesday and Sheff U are well supported so definitely a football city.

Burnley definitely pull in a big crowd for their catchment I think they are a bit like us as a club but not as big, I actually think the top two are us and Burnley.
I think us and Burnley are complete opposite’s myself. Burnley are a small standalone town surrounded by giants. They massively massively overachieve Middlesbrough is a town part of a larger contribution Teesside and we don’t have a major club within 40 minutes of the riverside I think we outpunch the likes of forest and Leicester and derby and some other outfits, there 1 million county’s each but I think our catchment area is similiar to clubs like wolves and sheff utd. Wolverhampton bigger than Middlesbrough but the metro population of Wolverhampton far smaller than that of Teesside. When you consider it’s half a million people for one club I don’t think in terms of population percentages it’s notable. Clubs like us Norwich Ipswich Sunderland all benefit from lack of competition for support and we have a monopoly of people to pull from compared to those in Lancashire and probably most efl clubs our support impressed me due to the lack of historical success and major underachievement I think the population argument is a bit of a myth. There’s no football clubs within a 40 mile radius of the riverside
 
I think Newcastle and Sunderland are about a million each when you include Blyth, North and South Shields, Whitley Bay/Tynemouth, Washington, Durham etc plus Northumberland and Durham counties. Newcastle perhaps 200k more as you say. I also know a few Scottish people who come down to Newcastle for matches.

I think ours is 500k.
All time average crowds when competing in the top flight. Safc 34k MFC 28k nufc 42k. It’s a media myth that it’s “ Sunderland and Newcastle “ in the same vein there much smaller than them and it kills then hence why they belittle us because they know there much more similiar in stature to us than them. There catchment area is larger and it reflects in there gates, and the happy meal tickets. The all time attendance table is a good dictator we are on par with wolves sheff utd and Birmingham. I think us 4 are all similar sized with similar catchment areas to draw from. Burnley and the other Lancashire clubs said above isn’t really a fair comparison imo, you could fit Burnley into teeside 5 times over
 
I think us and Burnley are complete opposite’s myself. Burnley are a small standalone town surrounded by giants. They massively massively overachieve Middlesbrough is a town part of a larger contribution Teesside and we don’t have a major club within 40 minutes of the riverside I think we outpunch the likes of forest and Leicester and derby and some other outfits, there 1 million county’s each but I think our catchment area is similiar to clubs like wolves and sheff utd. Wolverhampton bigger than Middlesbrough but the metro population of Wolverhampton far smaller than that of Teesside. When you consider it’s half a million people for one club I don’t think in terms of population percentages it’s notable. Clubs like us Norwich Ipswich Sunderland all benefit from lack of competition for support and we have a monopoly of people to pull from compared to those in Lancashire and probably most efl clubs our support impressed me due to the lack of historical success and major underachievement I think the population argument is a bit of a myth. There’s no football clubs within a 40 mile radius of the riverside


Personally think you are over egging ours abit there. Middlesbrough is not Teesside and Vice Versa. Yes Middlesbrough have some fans in the North Yorkshire villages etc but not big numbers and whey would we, what tie or affinity would people from a moors village have to Middlesbrough as a town, unless a parent was from there not a lot. The ones from Whitby etc are fans because a parent moved there, true locals from Whitby do not support Middlesbrough.
 
Personally think you are over egging ours abit there. Middlesbrough is not Teesside and Vice Versa. Yes Middlesbrough have some fans in the North Yorkshire villages etc but not big numbers and whey would we, what tie or affinity would people from a moors village have to Middlesbrough as a town, unless a parent was from there not a lot. The ones from Whitby etc are fans because a parent moved there, true locals from Whitby do not support Middlesbrough.
Transport links are usually important too, those moors villages mostly don’t have direct fast road and rail links. At a busy time it’s an hour drive from Whitby on rubbish roads. Two hour round trip to park, make it a three hour round trip door to door to the stadium. This is why places like Whitby are not big catchment areas for us
 
The catchment areas - approximately - works out about 3/2/1 Newcastle/Sunderland/Boro.

Newcastle about 1.5m
Sunderland about 1m
Boro about 500k.

It's very fuzzy as the South Tyneside/ County Durham split is very contentious, and Hartlepool have as many mackems / Geordies as Poolies.

Then for Boro, how far into North Yorkshire before it becomes dirty Leeds 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

But it's not that far off. Ish.
 
The catchment areas - approximately - works out about 3/2/1 Newcastle/Sunderland/Boro.

Newcastle about 1.5m
Sunderland about 1m
Boro about 500k.

It's very fuzzy as the South Tyneside/ County Durham split is very contentious, and Hartlepool have as many mackems / Geordies as Poolies.

Then for Boro, how far into North Yorkshire before it becomes dirty Leeds 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

But it's not that far off. Ish.
Are there any bog populouses in N Yorks that support Boro other than Northallerton and Thirsk due to the A19?
 
Personally think you are over egging ours abit there. Middlesbrough is not Teesside and Vice Versa. Yes Middlesbrough have some fans in the North Yorkshire villages etc but not big numbers and whey would we, what tie or affinity would people from a moors village have to Middlesbrough as a town, unless a parent was from there not a lot. The ones from Whitby etc are fans because a parent moved there, true locals from Whitby do not support Middlesbrough.
My point being there’s absolutely no comparison between us and Burnley. Historical average attendances has us as the best supported club to not win a fa cup Burnley are the smallest town fanbase to win the league complete opposite’s
 
Back
Top