I think that sums up a lot of supporters thoughts but next year in the Championship no guarantees we would repeat this season.The best in reason memory for sure. In some ways I would like another go in the championship wioth a full season of Carrick but prem must be the goal I guess
We will never be ready with this attitude. The chance is there for us now to get to the premier league. Let’s put everything into that.I agree with the sentiment, we'll only get better next season if we miss out in the playoffs. Loan signings under Carrick have been excellent and I'm sure he'll be able to repeat that with some astute signings over the summer if we are in this league next season. My heart wants promotion, but my head tells me we aren't ready and I worry we would implode again like last time with a season fighting relegation in the EPL.
Our club would be much healthier going up this season, amassing 0pts, than staying down in this division for another season.
No one will ever know if they're ready or not.
Do you think Sunderland (who 12 months ago were fighting for a play off spot in League 1) will think the same, 'Oh we're not ready, we're full of kids and loans' - of course not.
When the opportunity of going up arises, you grab it with both hands, irrespective of whether you think you're ready or not.
I actually subscribe to that, just don't see it as a massive disappointment if we don't go up and also don't think most of our fans are generally conditioned to the yo yo model. Can see the meltdowns on here when we lose two nil at home to Brentford in January amid the calls for Big SamOur club would be much healthier going up this season, amassing 0pts, than staying down in this division for another season.
No one will ever know if they're ready or not.
Do you think Sunderland (who 12 months ago were fighting for a play off spot in League 1) will think the same, 'Oh we're not ready, we're full of kids and loans' - of course not.
When the opportunity of going up arises, you grab it with both hands, irrespective of whether you think you're ready or not.
Well, if we want to get in the Champions League…..I actually subscribe to that, just don't see it as a massive disappointment if we don't go up and also don't think most of our fans are generally conditioned to the yo yo model. Can see the meltdowns on here when we lose two nil at home to Brentford in January amid the calls for Big Sam
I agree with the sentiment, we'll only get better next season if we miss out in the playoffs. Loan signings under Carrick have been excellent and I'm sure he'll be able to repeat that with some astute signings over the summer if we are in this league next season. My heart wants promotion, but my head tells me we aren't ready and I worry we would implode again like last time with a season fighting relegation in the EPL.
I trust Carrick to replace any players we lose with better or as good. Chuba will stay whatever I think, he's seen enough to know where he's happy. Steffen and Giles may well stay too, but aren't irreplaceable. Archer would be a fantastic signing, but there's more than us that would be interested if Villa were to sell. Don't get me wrong, I think it would be fantastic to go up, but think we've had a tremendous season whatever happens.Exactly.
We go up. We pretty much definitely hold onto Chuba and extend his contract. We possibly sign Archer on a permanent. Steffen and Giles too.
We don't go up, we feasibly lose 5 or 6 key players. We'd be even further away from "being ready" than we are now.
If we go up we take the money, trust the new recruitment principles - invest in younger players with resale value.
If we then go down you either cash in and are able to reinvest or you hold onto them for a year. Either way we'd hopefully be in a better position to then come straight back up.