If Villa are wanting a buyback clause on Archer, that would put off a lot of PL interest I’d suggest and possibly reduce his value. I do not like such contracts, but if it works financially, do it and worry about the consequences if it happens. We would not lose financially, it would be like a free loan, barring wages. If we don’t go up we have the player and Villa unlikely to invoke clause. If we go up, they would want to see how he faired in that first season and if he fired the goals to keep us up and they bought him back, then we’d still be in a better position than now. A buy back clause could work in our favour on this (clutching at straws, but I wont let go till its out of sight).