wilkos_perm
Well-known member
Carrick said that's what the ref told the coaching staff, it was in the gazette
Sending Off Incident
- Thread starter Millbrook
- Start date
Ab
Definitely heading towards to the goal and well away from the defenders.
Corcaigh_the_Cat
Well-known member
He was clean through, all he had to do was make a complete balls of it, and he would.
Anyway, good game, decent result for both sides, and our heavy handed stuff wasn't penalised either.
Thought the ref had a good game in the circumstances.
Anyway, good game, decent result for both sides, and our heavy handed stuff wasn't penalised either.
Thought the ref had a good game in the circumstances.
exeterboro
Well-known member
It's hard to say when you are there and so heavily invested in one outcome, unfortunately for the ref you could be right but that incident is big and he better of not saying anything to our coaching staff as what he has said just makes him look incompotent, I'm sure the club will report it back to the refs managers.
Norman_Conquest
Well-known member
I said on the match thread that I thought it was one of the few things he got wrong and other than that he had a good game.
Smoggyonthesolent
Well-known member
I think the issue is he goes down that often and leaves his legs in places to get caught that referees have doubt in their mind. I've seen it and think he needs to learn to drive past people and if he gets caught he will fall a lot more convincingly. However, definite freekick and lucky to stay on.
Last edited:
TeaCider
Well-known member
But that's a different issue entirely.
If the ref gives it as a foul, which he did, it's a red card.
It was a clear goalscoring opportunity and Jones was definitely moving towards goal.
If the ref hadn't given a foul because he thought Jones had dived, that would have made more sense than the situation we were left with.
Kevcharben
Well-known member
It was a clear red card in my view.
I would however offer a reason as to why the ref didnt send him off, as Jones was fouled, in falling he knocked the ball away from the goal, which he wouldnt have done if he wasnt impeded.
I agree not convinced he would been good enough to score but thats not the point.
I would however offer a reason as to why the ref didnt send him off, as Jones was fouled, in falling he knocked the ball away from the goal, which he wouldnt have done if he wasnt impeded.
I agree not convinced he would been good enough to score but thats not the point.
binghamered
Member
was the ref the VAR official that did the Spurs v Liverpool **** up? sounds like a disaster season for him
FabioPorkpie
Well-known member
68 minutes on here -
Definite red for me. Takes him out with a 2 handed push. Mind you, Drudy and Maddo didn’t even mention prospect of a red so
mfc.co.uk
Definite red for me. Takes him out with a 2 handed push. Mind you, Drudy and Maddo didn’t even mention prospect of a red so
Middlesbrough FC - Middlesbrough FC
Welcome to the official website of Middlesbrough Football Club. Visit for Boro's latest news, videos and highlights, plus tickets and match information.
mfc.co.uk
The Disciple
Well-known member
It’s annoying when you’re on the wrong end of this type of incident - if the player is sent off we probably win the game. We all remember last season when Fry got this marching orders in an almost identical situation. I did see one person on Twitter say there’s been a rule change for this type of situation but I’ve not heard there’s been any change? Anyway hopefully we get the rub of the green in our favour soon enough
Rofesleg
Well-known member
I can't remember now, but why did Fry get a red card and also concede a penalty?
Is it because the ref thought he fouled him on purpose, something like that?
TeaCider
Well-known member
The ref deemed that Fry made no attempt to play the ball, so it's still a red card.
It was actually very similar to this incident, with neither defender attempting to play the ball, except the ref in the Sunderland game decided it was in the box for Stewart (it wasn't in both cases) and correctly gave a red card.
If Jones had been fouled in the box, their player should still have been sent off alongside the penalty.
He was outside of the box, so it should just have been a red card.
pierrequiroule
Well-known member
68 minutes on here -
Definite red for me. Takes him out with a 2 handed push. Mind you, Drudy and Maddo didn’t even mention prospect of a red so
Middlesbrough FC - Middlesbrough FC
Welcome to the official website of Middlesbrough Football Club. Visit for Boro's latest news, videos and highlights, plus tickets and match information.
And here, 8.54 into the Matchday Live video, Jones ends up near the corner of the 6-yard box. So much for heading away from goal! As for losing control of the ball, it was clearly because of the shove in the back.
exeterboro
Well-known member
exeterboro
Well-known member
Not my name but screenshot from an Argyle website
MickaelDebevePhenomenal
Well-known member
If you compare it to the Sheff wed one, its farcical. Wednesday had a defender between the attacker and the goal, Bannan still gets a red. Here, Jones clean through, no covering defender, nailed on Red.
exeterboro
Well-known member
Thinking about the screenshot I supplied has probably changed my mind on if it is a penalty or not, in the snap the ball is starting to go away from him which means the contact happened briefly before the snap and at that pace would put it outside, but it's definitely a sending off.