Some really good points in this post, particularly by
@indeedido,
@parmoboy,
@Norman_Conquest and also
@Sexpom and
@fmttmadmin posing the counter arguments
The whole points thing is a really delicate issue and I'm really torn on it. On the one hand it seems common sense for those who shlep up and down the country on a regular basis to get first dibs for high demand games.
However, there is the argument put forward that over time it becomes a closed shop. I know Rob has said how can it be a closed shop if games are going to general sale. However, whilst many games going to general sale may well be the case at the moment it won't always be the case (I can't say either way as I haven't seen the stats, although if true I'd wager most general sales are midweek games, which are understandably more difficult to get time off work to get to).
We've had a few decidedly mixed seasons but if we're regularly challenging for automatic promotion at the top end of the Championship or even get into the Premier League then it's a different story for away ticket demand and the same faces will continually get the advantage pulling away points wise and monopolosing the away games. Many clubs who have run similar away schemes for longer than us have been criticised by their own fan bases for effectively running a closed shop in this way. If we go up at some point then we will 100% have the same issue. Which is why I can totally understand the arguments from those saying it is an unfair system that favours the few.
Ultimately, my biggest gripe with it all and probably why I just come down on the side of not being in favour of such a scheme is it is creating divisions amongst our own fan base. We are all Boro fans, but we are arbitrarily creating different categories of fans and effectively arguing who is best and deserves special dispensation. Fanatics that get to every game, Gold card holders, ST holders that get to 15 away games, STs who get to home games only, the geezer who lives in Lands End and can only get to one game a season. No one of us is any bigger or better a fan than another so should we not all have at least some chance of getting to experience that high demand exciting away game?
Could we potentially have a halfway house whereby those who go to every game buy an away season ticket (which they could once upon a time), allowing the diehards who never miss a match to guarantee a ticket but still allowing the vast majority of the fanbase to at least have a decent shot at getting away tickets? (As sales of away season tickets would be in the low 100's I would estimate, leaving a fair few up for grabs at even the most ramshackle hovel). I'm not sure if that would be a more palatable option? (Or even if by simply suggesting this I'm arguing against my point above that we're all Boro fans!
).
At the end of the day whatever system that's used is going to upset some people, so the club can't win.
NB: If you've stuck with my post this far reward yourself with a left over Christmas Quality Street, you've earned it!