What needs to happen over the summer then?

I guess our weakest positions this year have been LB, CDM, LW.

After that we've struggled with a second choice striker and getting the new 10 integrated.

Improve LB, CDM and LW and that third choice CF, then I think we should have enough to get play offs. This season has definitely been a transitional one, took too long to get the players in and assimilated, and we lacked another key CF option
I'd add a RB and 10 to that list. I think it will be important that we aim to sign a RB, LB, DM, 10 and LW, who we feel are going to be good enough for the first-team. Azaz could improve and make the no 10 position his own but at the moment there are still question marks there for me.

Prioritise getting those 5 signings right and then look to sign a low cost development striker, or take a punt on a player who may not necessarily have a proven track record, but has potential. I'd mentioned Ike Ugbo, who may be available on a free and could be worth taking a punt on.
 
I'd add a RB and 10 to that list. I think it will be important that we aim to sign a RB, LB, DM, 10 and LW, who we feel are going to be good enough for the first-team. Azaz could improve and make the no 10 position his own but at the moment there are still question marks there for me.

Prioritise getting those 5 signings right and then look to sign a low cost development striker, or take a punt on a player who may not necessarily have a proven track record, but has potential. I'd mentioned Ike Ugbo, who may be available on a free and could be worth taking a punt on.
I agree, I think that our backup cf should be technical player that can play 10 or cf covering those positions
 
We NEED someone who can tackle. A Mustoe, a Boateng, Ince. Watching Barlaser trying to tackle a rice pudding is killing me.
Not just tackle but press the ball properly without someone just drifting past him. We let a lot of goals in from shots from the edge of the box that are not being put under pressure. That's where a mustoe/Boateng/Ince type comes into their own and wins you games.
 
I think we need a few more players and a review of why our players this season have struggled with injuries so much. Is it training? The recovery side? Or just bad luck.
 
I think we need a few more players and a review of why our players this season have struggled with injuries so much. Is it training? The recovery side? Or just bad luck.
Some of the injuries are bad luck Lenihan, Smith, O'Brien, Hackney, they were caused by impact or excessive force when turning

We can argue that players like Lath and Coburn have had repeating injuries as they've been asked to play when not fully fit, caused by player workload

fry - persistent injuries, needs to get to the root cause of it instead of dealing with each instance of a muscle injury

Then the rest - maybe training is a key factor, we do get a lot of 'pulled up in training'
 
Screw that, I'm more looking forward to the Euros.😛

But to answer the question, whilst the season isn't quite over yet, the fat bint is certainly clearing her throat. Assuming as is overwhelmingly likely we're in the champo next season, I think a lot of our chances for promotion next time out will depend on our ability to keep hold of the players we can build the team around who offers will invariably come in for (Dieng, Rav, Hackney, Lath and probably Jones and Forss if fit) and making sure they're all fit and stay so as long as possible, the same going for other long term absentees.

We need to learn from our mistakes. Whilst Carrick is undoubtably still learning, the two biggest reasons we've not matched the 22/23 campaign are our playing a side of strangers at the start that effectively bu&&ered our autos chances whilst they settled and the horrendous unseen before long injury list that has all but knackered our chances of the playoffs into the bargain. If we can keep that core, have a largely settled side who are used to playing together and avoid a huge overhaul that scuppered our chances in the first 7 games of the season, it gets us off to a better start and please God if we can find out what went wrong that ensured we became Middlesbrough Hospital for the Critically Infirm then we should already do a great deal better. I'd suggest that an expected points tally of 80 points minimum if we do so could rightfully be expected. Arguably also it's less likely there will be 3 sides that will almost certainly hit over 90 points next season as those are something of a rarity.

Only after these should we prioritise those we're bringing in. Depending firstly on how many of that dependable 6 we keep hold of (easier at least than our core being made up of loans that were certain to go) and need replacing as a priority if we fail in this regard foremost.

If we want to have a stab at the autos, it's about those final few we bring in to enhance the side. O'brien is far from guaranteed to be here, Howson will be yet another year older, and Barlaser can blow hot and cold, so I'd make a CDM a priority even over a striker. Lath & Forss are definitely top championship standard if fit, with Coburn as a back up for Cup games, injury cover (provided its not 23/24 level injury cover) and to bring on for the last 20 - 30 minutes when the opposition tire. Another striker would definitely be handy, especially if other injuries put Forss out on the right, but I'd put CDM first on the list.

Regarding LB and RB it depends on how well Bangura recovers and beds back into the side as his pace can be frightening and with him on one side, Jones on the other and an also speedy Lath up top to aim at then we could have speed merchants wreaking havoc from both sides. This is coupled with an unknown concerning Smith's return, so a lot is a mystery for now. Ayling has shown enough so far IMHO so I'd get him signed properly and it would cost sweet fu(k all. Again LB would be a priority IF Bangura isn't up to scratch.
 
the two biggest reasons we've not matched the 22/23 campaign are our playing a side of strangers at the start that effectively bu&&ered our autos chances whilst they settled and the horrendous unseen before long injury list that has all but knackered our chances of the playoffs into the bargain.

I think the single biggest change is actually moving away from building our side around loan signings.

I'm in favour of using the loan market, but not as we used it last year. Use it to get that final bit of quality when you already have a strong squad (e.g. Gaston), or use it to add some depth to your squad like we're doing this year (ok, I know all 4 started the last match, but I don't think any would be in our first choice 11 if everyone was fit). I'm not in favour of 4 of our best 6 players being loanees, which was arguable the case last year.

The argument in favour of loans is that you can get, immediately, players of a higher calibre like Archer. That's great if you get promoted; if you don't, you've lost your money and you have to spend more money just to get back to where you were last year. If you bring in younger players and develop them, well you're not going to be as good straight away, but it's going to be more sustainable in the long run. That's, hopefully, where we've been this season.
 
1. We need a root and branch investigation into our injuries. We can have the best squad in the league but if we can't get them on the pitch it's pointless.

2. Retain our assets. We need to build our team around Hackney and RVDB. There may be a time when we're offered a figure we can't refuse but if we're serious about top 2 we need to do our damned hardest to keep them vested in our promotion push.

3. Recruitment.
3a. January was a good window in my opinion. It laid the foundations to allow us a big push this summer. We didn't spend frivolously on short term signings that eat up our FFP allowances. We didn't chase players for the sake of having a push for top 6 in a league that has vastly better teams in it that ours currently. We brought in good money for a player that didn't really have a huge impact on our season.
3b. First team Centre Forward, Right Back, Centre Midfield and Attacking midfielder should be priorities. I'm talking about players that are 'oven ready' Championship players.
3c. Finances allowing, i'd continue with the developmental signings. That has to continue if we're going to stay in this league.

4. Off the field relationship between the club and the fans. There's been a fair bit of damage done to that relationship with the ticket pricing and how it's been handled. Success is always a unifier but there needs to be some movement from the club to heal this relationship over the summer and renew that sense of optimism around the club and get us up and out the blocks quickly.
 
1. We need a root and branch investigation into our injuries. We can have the best squad in the league but if we can't get them on the pitch it's pointless.

By all means investigate.
I think we were generally very lucky with injuries in MC's first season; this year we've had more than average.
I suspect it's a fine tuning issue: peak physical condition is very close to cliff edge of being injury, and pushing it just a little too far can have disastrous results.
 
To win promotion from this league, you can leave no stone unturned as to do so would be a dereliction of duty. There is an incredible amount of sports science that monitors fatigue and physical conditioning at this level. It's very clear we haven't utilised that to the best of our abilities this season. That needs to change. It's way beyond bad luck to me.
 
I don't know I'd call it bad luck, but some injuries, Hugill on Jones for example, are beyond sports science. The potential for that to happen in this sport is always there and is beyond our control.

I don't disagree with the rest of what you say though.
 
To win promotion from this league, you can leave no stone unturned as to do so would be a dereliction of duty. There is an incredible amount of sports science that monitors fatigue and physical conditioning at this level. It's very clear we haven't utilised that to the best of our abilities this season. That needs to change. It's way beyond bad luck to me.
I'd also add it seems pretty clear we've brought players back from lay-offs who have been injured again, Lath, Forss, Hackney, Coburn and Bangura have all had spells out and then another injury lay off shortly after returning, (McGree too but he was injured with the Aussies I suppose so not directly our choice/fault.

We wouldn't be rushing back / utilising players so quickly if the squad rotation option was better.

It seems mad that whilst having ten players missing on occasion for chunks of this season that Gilbert, Hoppe and most of the youth players have barely been utilised. If you add Coulson and Billongo to that, we have 'squad' players who aren't trusted to be used it seems. Hopefully if we sign the four or five starters we need (for a promotion push) that gives us much stronger rotation options to rest and mange players who aren't 100%.
 
Last edited:
By all means investigate.
I think we were generally very lucky with injuries in MC's first season; this year we've had more than average.
I suspect it's a fine tuning issue: peak physical condition is very close to cliff edge of being injury, and pushing it just a little too far can have disastrous results.
I guess there's a domino affect as well. As the squad becomes thinner, players play through niggles or rushed back etc and that can lead to more serious injuries. Coburn seems to have been a victim of this, maybe McGree, potentially others.
 
I think we were generally very lucky with injuries in MC's first season; this year we've had more than average.
Not so sure, we got 8 games out of Ramsey before he got broken; 6 out of Clarke and he broke down; Crooks had hernia issues and an op; Darnell Fisher had ameobiitis; Fry missed 20 matches through the season; Jones missed about 25% of the season but possibly more psychological than injuries; McNair had injuries and of course Akpom started the season injured and ended it trying to play through a serious injury.

It wasn't anywhere near as bad as this year, but there were some key players injured for a long time or at key moments like the play offs.
 
Fry missed 20 matches through the season

I was musing on Fry's injuries the other day so looked him up. I then compared him to Ayala, I found it a bit surprising as one is seen or commented on as a running joke sick note who didn't play February to March. (it also reinforces how woeful Fry is on set pieces!)


Screenshot 2024-04-10 at 11.48.07.png

Screenshot 2024-04-10 at 11.49.28.png
 
His appearances record isn't great. I'd understand wanting to sell on that basis but i wouldn't sell him because he doesn't score from corners.
 
Back
Top